What To Do When You’re An Asshole

I’m a bit of an asshole and by that, I mean I’m a pretty big asshole. It’s a problem I’ve been trying to deal with for some time now, but it’s proving to be hard to shake. My sarcastic responses are deeply rooted, years of self-protective reflexes have led me to go for the jugular and I tend to be pretty impulsive, which doesn’t help matters much. I’ve been trying to watch what I say and be mindful of how I come off, yet no matter how hard I try, and even though it’s rather large, my foot always manages to find its way to my mouth with surprising ease.

An Asshole’s Options

So, what to do? Well, there’s the obvious answer… Stop being an asshole, but that really hasn’t worked out. It’s one of those easier said than done kind of things… So what does that leave? Well, you can just be okay with being an asshole, but honestly, I’m not. I wish I was one of those people who didn’t feel bad after I did something awful, but, annoyingly, my emotional awareness tends to catch up to my impulsive actions. You can find people who like assholes, and thankfully they exist, but sadly our appeal is not quite as great as we’d like to believe. So all that’s left is to accept that you’re an asshole, but still find ways to improve.

Where An Asshole Should Start

The temptation is to focus on diminishing the negative, on being less of an asshole, but I’ve found it to be an ineffective tactic. It turns out, at least for me, the better approach wasn’t to stop doing things that hurt others (although I’ll want to get around to that eventually). I’ve been far better off enhancing my positive qualities first before dealing with the abundant negative ones.

Even An Asshole Has Strengths

Chances are, if you’re one of the people who is actually aware of and worries about being an asshole, you have them. If you’re not worried, well, why the hell are you reading this? But I digress… Let these natural strengths lead the way. Emphasize what’s working for you and let that enhance your relationships. Don’t get me wrong, the whole asshole thing is far from acceptable, but if you’ve been one long enough, it isn’t all that easy to change. And frankly, since you’re an asshole, people will know when you’re faking.

Don’t Pretend You’re Not An Asshole

Don’t pretend to be nice; focus on enhancing the (likely few) areas of your life where you already are. One of the downsides (and occasional upside) to being an asshole is being fairly transparent, so a charade really isn’t going to help much of anything. However, this same vulnerability can be just the redeeming quality you need. Vulnerability is relatable… well, at least it is when you don’t use it as an excuse to cut someone else to shreds…

What Came First? The Chicken Or The Asshole?

Impulsivity and insensitivity come into play, but a big part of being an asshole is often just being defensive. It’s often all about self-protection, but more often than not, all that you end up doing is isolating yourself. Much as I tend to enjoy them, most people don’t like assholes. And when people don’t like an asshole… well, the asshole tends to become an even bigger asshole. It’s an annoying cycle for everyone, so just stop it already…

Lean on your (again, likely few) strengths; when you do, there tends to be far fewer reasons to put your negative instincts in the driver’s seat. By leading with the positive rather than indulging in the negative, you cut down on the need to lash out. When you see the difference this can make, you can’t help but take notice and find yourself wanting to be less of an asshole (or at least a little less of one). Let that build long enough and you might just start actively trying not to be one. It’s no easy feat, but it can often be a worthy one… trust me, I speak from experience here…

  • http://yuvizalkow.com/ Yuvi Zalkow

    I also wonder if sometimes what you call an asshole is really just a sort of blunt, honest feedback that is more direct than most people are used to… I know you’ve given me some pretty pointed advice at times that I found hard-but-refreshing… you might unfairly label that as ‘being an asshole’ but I’d disagree… Do you buy that?

    • http://michaelschechter.me/ MSchechter

      It’s a combination. I think I have both asshole gears, the defensive and the blunt (I actually wrote a follow up that addresses some of this), but I still think for many that still reads as asshole. My heart might be in the right place, but my foot can often be inserted into my mouth. I’ve also made it clear to you in the past that, “I may sound like an asshole here” which I think helps it seem less assholic :)

      • http://yuvizalkow.com/ Yuvi Zalkow

        I’ve also made it clear to you in the past that, “I may sound like an asshole here” which I think helps it seem less assholic :)

        Yes. I’ve used that method plenty myself. The I’m-An-Asshole Caveat…

      • trchandler

        I may sound like an asshole here, but I think this technique is a cop out. It does help change the other person’s expectations around what they are about to hear, but it shows little flexibility to adjust to the other persons preferences. It’s a little like saying, “I was just joking.”

        • http://michaelschechter.me/ MSchechter

          Not an asshole at all (and if you can’t be an asshole with this post, where can you be one :) ).

          So two things. One, you’re right, it is a cop out. I’d be better off not being an asshole or knowing how to better couch my opinions at times. That said, I don’t see it as the same as “just kidding”. In fact, it’s very much the opposite. When I go here, it’s far more for the reason that I believe something is important and needs to be stated clearly.

          Much as I need to learn to couch things in a better way, it’s all to common that the message gets lost in people trying to be nice.

          • trchandler

            I can see your point about the differences between “just kidding” (JK) and “I may sound like an asshole” (IMSLA). JK is reactionary and apologetic, where IMSLA is pre-emptive and signals to the listener to focus on the content and not the tone.

            The similarity I saw between the two is that they both shift responsibility from the speaker to the listener. And like “REAL CHEESE” on the side of Cheez-It box, the more you have to say these things, the less sincere they feel over time.

            Instead of IMSLA, why not something like, “I have something to say that I think could be really helpful. May I be blunt and direct with you?”

            On a personal note: I’m an asshole, too. I like to be direct and blunt. I like to argue with people, especially other assholes. Mine rears it’s head when I see stupidity in action. I have a very low tolerance for that. Great post that really got me thinking. Thanks.

          • http://michaelschechter.me/ MSchechter

            To be 100% honest, I don’t know if I really see the difference between those two statements (I tend to be very desensitized to profanity :) ). I also use something like it just as often. As for the sincerity issue, I don’t know that it loses it if you only use it sincerely.

            I guess what I’m really saying is what you say after “I’m going to be an asshole here, but I think it’s important” (or some variation thereof) matters far more than the couching/setup.

  • Robert

    Developing meditation capability helped me in this area. (Although, to be honest, so did aging and since both — aging and meditation — happened concurrently, it’s not clear which was responsible for the positive effect.)

  • trchandler

    I just had this conversation with my 15yo son. As I listened to him interact with his friends, he was an asshole. At work, we had just interviewed four candidates for promotion. The person with the strongest skill set was also the biggest asshole. That was seen by the interviewers as a huge liability.

    I shared that with my son, and told him the importance of knowing your audience. He can be an asshole with me, or his best bud (also an asshole), but when he’s talking to a girl he likes, he would be better served to change his tone and be more strategic with his word choices.

    We framed it not as be less of an asshole, but rather what other styles can you add to your repertoire instead of always defaulting to the natural asshole style. The more styles you develop, the more flexibility you have, and ultimately, the more successful you’ll be.

    Sharing: Thought this was a great podcast discussion on the use of the word asshole. http://www.slate.com/articles/podcasts/lexicon_valley/2012/09/the_rise_of_the_asshole_lexicon_valley_talks_with_linguist_geoffrey_nunberg_.html

    • http://michaelschechter.me/ MSchechter

      Wise advice and it’s amazing that you can speak to him so frankly about it. I know it has held me back at time, but I also haven’t gotten to the point where I can fully get away from it either. Little by little, but your son will have a serious advantage with you helping him navigate this so early on in his life.

  • HappyKreg

    This article has made my respect for you double.

    • http://michaelschechter.me/ MSchechter

      I’m torn between that respect being higher and my secret fear that the starting point was zero :)